Tag Archives: early career

Research integrity and AI: how universities are preparing Australia’s emerging scientists

Research apprenticeships are a valuable part of Australia’s innovation, research, and development ecosystem. At their core, they involve experienced academic supervisors supporting novice researchers. But the nature of this apprenticeship is quickly changing, increasingly powered by AI technologies.

Such apprenticeships can include students enrolled in a Higher Degree by Research (HDR) or Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), as well as Early Career Researchers (ECRs). This training is designed to help next-generation researchers develop the knowledge, judgement and critical-thinking skills to navigate their future careers.

Starting with integrity

Associate Professor Janine Arantes from Victoria University is an HDR supervisor and expert on AI ethics, psychosocial risk and education policy. 

When taking on new research apprentices, Arantes says conversations “absolutely have to start with integrity”. That includes consideration of ethical principles and adherence to professional research standards. Without attention to research integrity, a multi-year project like a PhD isn’t worth the paper it’s written on. Some experts believe it might even be an appropriate time to revive the discussion of viva voce examinations for PhDs in Australia. 

As an HDR manager, Associate Professor Maggie Zhai from RMIT University believes supervisors must guide their students as technology shifts. As HDR manager in the School of Science, Zhai encourages supervisors to keep up with AI to best provide critical training and insights to the next generation of researchers.

Zhai believes that with supervisors taking a leading role in AI use and literacy, they can guide students on the things “feared most for research apprenticeship”. This includes developing judgment, thinking critically and avoiding plagiarism.

Many Australian HDR supervisors echo these sentiments, according to forthcoming research conducted by Jisi A, a Victoria University PhD candidate supervised by Arantes. “Supervisors see clear benefits in using generative AI for efficiency and research support, but they are also cautious about issues such as accuracy and research integrity,” he says.

Levelling the field?

There is clear tension over whether – and how – generative AI (genAI) might level the academic playing field. Zhai, Arantes and their students see benefits and risks, depending on the circumstances. They outline a range of scenarios. 

GenAI can generate “really beautiful diagrams, schemes, data or figure plots,” says Zhai. This allows novice researchers to spend less time planning their communication, though it can lead to questions about the competence and capability of the student.  

Unfortunately, research apprentices who have the most to gain from AI assistance may also be the least equipped to recognise when AI is wrong, according to Arantes. Her approach is to encourage necessary friction. “You have to be exposed to ideas you don’t necessarily agree with,” she says. This helps to develop critical thought and rigorous research.

Dr Lorenn Ruster, an ECR at the Australian National University, wonders if genAI might level the field for researchers in another way. She recalls how the scaffolded support of the PhD research apprenticeship helped her start a conversation with a journal on their AI policies, after receiving vague reviewer feedback generated with AI. Hurdles like these could be significant setbacks without an experienced supervisor, highlighting how in the age of AI, research apprenticeships may be more necessary than ever before.

Supporting a whole ecosystem

Arantes says that AI frameworks need to be supported by best practice policy and signed legislation. She argues there needs to be capability building across the whole higher education ecosystem, not just in research apprenticeships.

There is a future where HDRs are trained to use AI while overcoming risks to critical thinking, judgement and communication. “This requires positive and behavioural changes”, says Zhai.

 – Written by Ella McCarthy

Early career researchers take the stage

The Showcasing Early Career Researchers Competition celebrates good research that is well communicated. Entrants were asked to submit a 30-second video conveying the aim of their research. Five finalists were selected from 41 entrants to attend the 2017 CRC Association Annual Conference in Canberra, to give a 5-minute presentation. An audience vote at the Collaborate Innovate conference determined the winner. 

Meet the five Showcasing Early Career Researchers finalists and see a 30 second snapshot of their work. 

WINNER 2017

JULIE BEADLE – The HEARing CRC

HEARING LOSS IN OLDER ADULTS

early career researchers

Many older adults struggle to understand speech in everyday noisy situations, even when they perform well on traditional hearing tests. For my PhD, I am investigating how age-related changes in cognitive functioning contribute to this all too common situation. I aim to develop a listening test that is reflective of communication in real life and examine how age and cognitive skills like attention and memory are related to performance on this test.

Watch Julie’s video

FINALISTS 2017 

JACQUILINE DEN HOUTING – Autism CRC

TOO ANXIOUS TO ACHIEVE

early career researchers

Around 40% of autistic people experience anxiety, and autistic people also tend to underperform academically. In the non-autistic population, a link between these two issues has been found.

In my research, I am using assessments of anxiety and academic achievement with a group of autistic students, to identify whether the same link exists within the autistic community. These findings could inform support options for autistic students, allowing for improved mental health and academic outcomes.

Watch Jacquiline’s video

DORIS GROSSE – Space Environment Research Centre

MANAGING SPACE DEBRIS

early career researchers

Several 100,000 space debris objects orbiting Earth are threatening to collide with and destroy our satellites networks. To prevent those collisions, a ground based laser can be aimed at the debris objects moving them out of the way with the help of photon pressure. The atmosphere, however, distorts the laser beam. The Adaptive Optics system that I am building compensates for those distortions so that the laser beam can be focused correctly on the object in space and hence preventing collisions.

Watch Doris’s video

TOMAS REMENYI – Antarctic Climate & Ecosystems CRC

TACKLING CLIMATE CHANGE

Early career researchers

The Climate Futures Team translates fine-scale, regional climate model output into useful, usable tools that are used by decision makers in industries across Australia. Our focus is on working closely with industry during research design, and throughout the process, to ensure the outputs of our research are directly relevant to our stakeholders and align with their decision making frameworks.

Watch Tomas’s video

MELISSA SCOTT – Autism CRC

WORKPLACES FOR ALL

Early career researchers

Despite people with autism having high levels of skills and the desire to work, they remain unemployed. Many employers are hesitant to hire people with autism due to their lack of confidence and knowledge about autism. To assist employers to better understand autism and their specific needs in the workplace, the Integrated Employment Success Tool (IEST) has been developed. The IEST is a practical “tool kit” with strategies to help employers tailor the workplace for success for people with autism.

Watch Melissa’s video

This article on the Showcasing Early Career Researchers Competition was first published by the CRC Association. Read the original article here.

Connecting graduates with businesses

Gaining industry experience and seeing how their research can have practical applications is important to early career researchers. Universities and industry are now working together to help provide graduates with the opportunity to work on commercial solutions for real-life problems.

Sally Bradford won the 2015 Showcasing Early Career Researchers competition, and is a PhD candidate in clinical psychology at the University of Canberra. She developed an electronic mental health assessment app allowing physicians to diagnose and support their patients’ previously undisclosed issues. Bradford’s research is part of a larger collaborative project with the Young and Well CRC.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qdS9BzWEafE&feature=youtu.be

Perth-based cancer immunotherapy research group Selvax Pty Ltd has entered a commercial partnership with Curtin University. They signed a two-year contract to develop anti-cancer immunotherapy treatments in November 2015, after CEO Tony Fitzgerald saw value in Curtin Senior Research Fellow Dr Delia Nelson’s ten years of research into immunological agents.

“We want access to innovative research to make practical use of what researchers are discovering,” says Fitzgerald.

These industry partnerships aren’t new. “It’s a well-trodden path in the USA,” says Fitzgerald.

“But it’s not as common in Australia – we’re great at innovating, but not great at commercialising our work.”

Perth-based energy company Bombora Wave Power needed to know what sensors would work underwater with its unique wave energy converter (WEC), so they partnered with Edith Cowan University (ECU) through the university’s Industry and PhD Research Engagement Program, which matches Western Australian PhD candidates with industry. ECU graduate Gary Allwood researched ways of using optical fibre sensors to measure load and stress on the WEC system’s membrane.

“The partnership allowed me to do things that haven’t been done before, like use optical fibres as sensors instead of electrical sensors,” says Allwood, who will work with Bombora Wave Power to test the sensors.

There are other, similar Australian programs. CRCs offer a number of scholarships across 14 different fields of research, giving PhD students a chance to gain industry experience.

Monash University started its Graduate Research Interdisciplinary Programs (GRIPs) in early 2015, allowing PhD students to solve real-world problems through collaborative research.

The Chemicals and Plastics GRIP has 20 industry partners offering training and funding, including Dulux and 3M. One student is treating coffee grounds to create a fertiliser to improve the soil quality of agricultural land.

“This is an exciting and innovative model for postgraduate education that encourages interdisciplinary and industry-engaged practice,” says Monash University’s Vice-Provost for Graduate Education, Professor Zlatko Skrbis.

– Marisa Wikramanayake